Qualifications vs experience in HR in 2011
When looking to fill human resources vacancies, it is important that you know exactly what it is you are looking for beforehand or the wealth of applicants may seem overwhelming. In today's climate there are more applicants per post than ever before and each will be trying to sell themselves to you as much as possible.
You will need to have an idea of the type of person that will fit into your organisation as well as the type of qualifications you are looking for from your candidate and this is where it can become difficult for many people. Do you want a candidate who is academically qualified or do you want someone who has experience in the role you are trying to fill?
Qualifications vs. experience is one of the more difficult decisions an employer must make as there are positives and negatives to each type of candidate and different posts may warrant a different attitude. Generally speaking, applicants with academic qualifications and little experience will be easier to train to your way of thinking whilst experienced applicants may come bursting with great ideas that they have used elsewhere to good effect. So, the question is, what do you want?
Look for experienceIf your business is new it might be a good idea to take on someone with a wealth and variety of experience. You may have to pay them more money than you had originally intended but the benefit to your organisation will be worth it.
A widely experienced Human Resources professional will be able to assist you in setting up all the policies and procedures that your company will require to function. If you choose someone with recent experience, they should also have a good working knowledge of employment law and legislation that can save you time and money in the long run.
Experienced staff will also be able to help you manage the rest of your team and offer innovative advice based on their past experiences. In the context of new business, experience is often the best choice as they will be able to assist you with areas of the business that you are unsure of.
In established companies, experience is also often preferred over academic qualification and this is especially true when you are looking to fill a vacancy internally. Internal staff know your business best and, even if they have not been working within the HR department, they should be able to demonstrate at interview a wide working knowledge of the existing HR policies and guidelines.
Often, staff members who are moving in from other departments such as training and development, frontline management or administrative positions are ideally situated to identify any issues with the existing department. Their knowledge and experience of the culture and staff of the business can be invaluable in pushing forward and managing any situations that may arise.
If, however, you are looking to recruit an entirely new member of staff to an existing team, there are two things that you must consider; are you recruiting because of an existing issue or are you just in need of a new team member?
Tackling specific issues
If you are recruiting in order to get help for an on-going or existing issue, an experienced human resources professional may be the perfect solution. You can even use the situation as a hypothetical interview question in order to gauge in advance if there are any candidates with experience uniquely suited to tackling the problem.
If, however, you are looking for a supporting member of staff or a manager who you would like to merely take up the reins of an existing set of processes, a recently qualified professional with little experience would be your perfect choice.
Candidates with recent qualifications will be right up to date with employment laws and will be able to easily slot into their expected roles as they will bring no expectations from previous posts. This type of candidate can be ideal if you are looking for support for an existing department, as it will be very easy for the team to update them quickly.
Experience versus qualifications is a question that can really only be answered dependent on the circumstances under which you intend to hire. Think closely about what you require, taking the above into consideration and it should help you whittle down your interview list, making the choice that much easier for you.









The promotion of wellbeing in the workplace is the main objective of the Liberal Democrats’ new policy paper; A New Purpose for Politics: Quality of life.
Although it is a legal requirement for men and women to receive equal pay when performing the same role, the reality is that on average women are still paid less than men. Many well meaning organisations struggle with identifying or rectifying issues in this area.
Working in a company that organises a weekly game of football for staff to play, and has a gym downstairs, I certainly appreciate an employer that helps promote good health. As such, I was interested in reading about an award and framework for promoting this aspect of the workplace.